Mine were comfy out of the box. I haven’t worn them all day on my feet yet but I suppose it shouldn’t be an issue once they’re broke in. All leather boots are usually more comfortable in the long run. They feel a little big but I think once the leather breaks in they will fit near perfect, I take a 12 so that’s what I ordered but I could probably fit an 11.5. Highly recommend. They ought to hold up good being roughout.